Many shades of Calabar Carnival 2017
Since 2004 when former Governor of Cross River State, Mr. Donald Etim Duke, introduced the Calabar Carnival, as part of activities to mark Christmas celebrations, the quality of the celebration in the state has dramatically changed. And from its humble beginning, it has now become an international event, which several countries take part in.
Hitherto, the state used to package it as a month-long event, which usually begins from December 1st, with the switching on of the Christmas tree. On the timetable, the needs of locals and tourists were adequately served.
When Senator Liyel Imoke took over in 2007, he sustained the tempo and even introduced the mountain race, which boosted the celebrations, and attracted tourists and elite athletes to the state.
However, since Senator Ben Ayade mounted the saddle as governor, he shrank the hitherto month-long festivities to just two week, and without a detailed timetable as was the case.
The 2017 edition, with the theme “Migration,” did not start with the usual tree-lighting, but the Christmas Village at Calabar Municipal Council was in place right from December 1, and thousands had fun buying and selling.
Other events that were part of this year’s celebration were the display of major Cross River State and some African cuisines, which was coordinated by Senator Florence Ita-Giwa. There was also the Calabar Carnival Bikers Parade, and motor race, which featured exotic cars; Miss Africa Beauty Pageant; the main carnival float and the international carnival, as well as, old people’s beauty contest.
Ayade and Duke wowed the crowd with their exotic bikes in the bikers’ parade, which featured over 250 bikers from Nigeria, Togo and Morocco, on December 27. Showboating Ayade participated with his Red Scorpio Tricycle, after displaying his vintage convertible car.
During the Miss Africa contest, Ayade, called for the integration of the African continent, reasoning that it should work as one country in order to facilitate development, and urged Africans seeking greener pastures to return and help build the continent.
Ayade whose speech centred on migration, said it was made to draw the attention of the world to the problems of illegal migration bedeviling the country and other African countries today.
He said: “Today in Calabar, we have people from the United States, Germany, Mexico, Sweden and others celebrating with us in this carnival; we want to tell them that Africa is so rich. Sometimes we begin to wonder why we have young Africans going through Morocco, the Mediterranean Sea, Sahara desert and all these difficult routes to find themselves in Libya, where they are being used as slaves and treated as sub-human beings.”
He said the carnival was to “tell the world that Africa is the richest continent. Africa is blessed; we have everything; and we have no reason, as young men and young women to struggle to leave the African continent. We are telling this story of pain, melancholy and frustration that indeed, the best place you can be is Africa.”
Some of the beauty queens, who decried why Africans should engage in illegal migration, urged youths to stay back in their countries and get the best of them.
They equally urged African leaders to provide an enabling environment, create empowerment programmes for their youths, just as they described illegal migration as second and modern-day slavery.
At the end of the contest, which is in its second year, Gaseangwe Balopi of Botswana emerged the winner, and took home $35, 000 and a Ford Edge Sport Utility Vehicle.
Miss Rwanda, Fiona Naringwa and Miss Luyolo Mngonyama of South Africa were first and second runners-up in that order, taking home $10, 000 and $5, 000 respectively.
The carnival despite having the largest crowd-ever has been widely viewed as a flop considering the fact that tourists and visitors seemed not to have enjoyed the carnival float.
The float, which was billed for flag-off by 10:00 a.m. on Thursday, December 28, at the Millennium Park (also known as the 11-11 Roundabout) did not begin till past 4:00 p.m. when the governor arrived.
Signs of trouble began to show when an announcement the night before said all bands were to muster at 11-11 Roundabout, instead of having the five competing bands of Passion 4, Bayside, Freedom, Masta Blasta and Seagull muster at five different points along the 12 kilometre carnival route, a development that affords everyone the opportunity to watch at least three performing bands within a span of four hours.
The first non-competing bands arrived at the U. J. Esuene Stadium at 12:30 a.m. on Friday, and by 6:00 a.m., Passion Four Band was yet to perform. By this time also, all the revelers were tired, frustrated and too weak to continue.
Pop sensation, Patoranking threatened to leave when he was called on stage to perform and after his performance, about 80 per cent of the audience members departed, leaving behind a scanty stadium for Passion 4 Band to perform.
By some minutes past 7:00 a.m. on Friday, Mr. Gabe Onah, who heads the Cross River Carnival Commission announced the winning band before a scanty crowd at the stadium, as some of the revelers had stayed awake for 25 hours as at 8:00 a.m. that Friday morning.
On December 29, the international carnival, which many looked forward to, ended abruptly for those who are not at home with the idea of public display of nudity. While some female participants from the United States and Kenya were scantily clad, their counterparts from South Africa put their breasts on display. This forced some parents to scurry their wards away from the stadium during the display.
This attracted scathing criticisms from some attendees and citizens alike, who wondered at the rationale behind Ayade’s cancellation of the Obudu Mountain Race, which he said was because the state was spending so much money, but without any benefits to the people, as Nigerians were not winning the event.
The critics were also quick to point out that the same government is spending as much money on the beauty pageant and the international carnival, which they allege was glamorising nudity and prostitution.
Italy, Mexico, France, Croatia, Ethiopia, Lithuania and others performed in the international carnival, but it was performances by contingents from the USA and South Africa that were culturally shocking, and got some eyes popping, while that of the Kenyans was typically African.
Generally speaking, the carnival lacked coordination and crowd control was poor, while security operatives were clearly overzealous. Some spectators, who have been part of the carnival for over five years said they did not enjoy this year’s outing because performances/displays were mainly done at adjudication points that were heavily crowded.
In addition to that, because of the new arrangement, they had to wait for lengthy periods before the next band showed up to perform. Consequently, most people that lined the carnival route only ended up feeding their eyes on tired carnival revelers trekking down the road instead of dancing.
Ekomobong Akpan, a resident of Sokoto, who was in Calabar for the festivities rated the carnival as “barely considering that expectations were very high as a result of the frenzy created around the carnival. But these expectations were really not met and the planning was a bit off the mark. Most people came in to enjoy the spectacle and to take photos, but because of poor time management, and the late commencement, the carnival suddenly ran into the night. Given the fact that the show has been on for more than a decade now, better planning would have been done.”
But for another visitor, Mr. Nosakhare Ehiarinmwian from Benin, Edo State, “the carnival was really interesting, especially the attire worn by members of the respective bands. I equally really enjoyed the bikers’ parade, which I considered a very stylish addition that has the power to attract much more bikers in the years to come from within and outside the country if sufficient awareness is created.”
The Managing Director of the state’s tourism bureau, Mr. Clement Unimna, while doing a post-mortem on the carnival said, “the carnival is a tourism product, but we are not doing it so. I think the state government needs to redefine exactly its understanding of Calabar Carnival in terms of whether it is a tourism product, or it is just a let-us-get-happy together kind of show. If it is truly a tourism product the way we started, then the government needs to do a rethink on the money being spent on the carnival. When you spend more than 80 per cent of what you budgeted to get foreigners to come and participate in the carnival when the reverse should be the case, is it being done as a tourism business?”
He continued: “Cross River State started carnival in Nigeria, therefore it should by now be sufficiently blessed with experts that are well versed with planning, organising and execution of the carnival. So, why do we have non-Cross Riverians handling key consultancy roles in organising and managing the carnival? That means you are depriving the people of their legitimate right to grow themselves economically. A case in point is the consultant for the international carnival.
“If people are invited and the state government spends money to bring them down here to be part of the carnival, then that is not tourism. If people spend all their time, save money and come to witness carnival and do not have proper places to sit or proper value for their money in terms of what is offered to them, where they can spend money, and they go back with the money in their pockets, that is not tourism. When people come and check into hotels and restaurants that are less than ready for such crowd, rather than the people enjoying themselves, they go away with agony in their hearts, that is also not tourism. When you have security officials flogging attendees with horsewhips and even injuring them in the name of crowd control, that is not tourism. So, a lot needs to be done in these aspects.
“The regulatory component of the event has to step up and government has to know that as it’s spending money to build the bands, they should also spend money to build the ancillary or augmenting products of tourism. For instance, make the sites and attractions around Calabar to be visitor-ready,” he advised.
However, the Special Adviser to the Governor on Event Management, Mr. Ken Aklah, described the carnival as a huge success considering the unprecedented crowd that turned out. “The crowd turnout was very impressive even though we believe that time management was a little constrained since we returned mustering to the central point. Because of that, a lot of people ended up seeing the first carnival a bit late. But in terms of crowd response, it grew tremendously, and this shows that people are gradually getting entrenched, and believing that the carnival is one place to be at this time of the year.”
Commenting on the overzealousness displayed by security operatives, Aklah said, “Yes, I cannot say that we got everything right, even though these security operatives are trained. We have tried to let them understand that they don’t need to use horsewhips on crowd members because tourism is about getting people interested in what you are doing, and not coming to push or shove them around. Accepted there would be instances like that because the crowd almost overwhelmed everybody, but any such ugly incident is highly regrettable.”
Many stakeholders are bothered by the inability of the state government to weave activities around tourist sites in the state into the festivities. But Aklah said doing so was “work in progress, as most of our tourists’ sites are not within Calabar, but well outside the state capital and the roads which are extremely bad. People rate Cross River tourism from the perspective of national tourism as if we are a nation. Cross River State is a state within a nation and much of the infrastructural development we need to put in place to drive tourism belong, to the Federal Government, including most of the roads.”
He denied that the state government spent N3billion on this year’s carnival, noting that, “the figure is outrageous. Do you believe that Cross River State has N3billion to put into the carnival when we have salaries and others things to take care of? Inflow from the Federation Account is slightly above N2billion monthly, which is not enough to pay salaries. This government tried to fix some roads around December, and this was not part of the carnival, but a normal duty of government. These are some of the things that people put together to arrive at these humongous figures. On the carnival itself, I wonder if we even spent up to N500million?”
Passion 4 Band beat four other contenders to emerge winners of the 2017 Carnival Calabar, while Freedom Band and Bayside Band took second and third positions.
No comments yet